Books to Make You Laugh & Think
booklist by JonIrwin
DJR Suggested Reads
Welcome, Guest!
join djr  |  help
EARMARKED | MESSAGES | SUBSCRIPTIONS
 
Shelf Comments
There are no comments for this book yet.
Shelve this book and share yours.
Book Quips - bulletin board
No one has posted a public comment about this book yet.

    Wide Sargasso Sea (Essential.penguin)

    [see reviews - 2]    review this book     add to your shelf    

    sbarranca's Review
    review by sbarranca
    I read to escape and I escape to read!
    overall book rating: 95%
     

    I just finished Wide Sargasso Sea for the second time; this book stands up to countless readings.  I don't know if Jean Rhys was the first novelist to tell "the other side of the story" ; I have since read more novels that follow this theme, such as Ahab's Wife and The Red Tent.  Some of these retellings work well and some fall flatRhys's Wide Sargasso Sea not only works, but it actually manages to rewrite Jane Eyre itself. (which I think would please Rhys as she was not a fan of English culture or the English as a people)

    Rhys creates the life story of Antoinette Bertha Mason; the character who was created by Charlotte Bronte in Jane Eyre, but Rhys is the author who gives her life.  Antoinette "Bertha" Mason was the creole mad woman locked in Mr. Rochester's attic in Jane Eyre, but that is all we really know about her.  She is depicted as wild, inhumane, savage, and consumed with madness.  How did this woman end up mad?  How did she end up in the attic in the first place?  Are we to believe everything Mr. Rochester tells Jane after he is exposed as attempting bigamy?

     Rhys creates a life and a story for Antoinette before she was imprisoned in the attic.  Rhys successfully creates a prequel to Jane Eyre that manages to superimpose Rhys's story over the one given to us in Jane Eyre.  After reading Wide Sargasso Sea, one cannot read Jane Eyre the same way again.  As Antoinette says in the novel, "there is always another side, always the other side of the story." 

    Antoinette's story is told in three parts.  The first part is predominately told in Antoinette's voice; this part gives us glimpses into her childhood and leads us up to her marriage with Mr. Rochester.  The second part is told by Edward Rochester, and even though he makes choices we wish he doesn't, and he ends by hurting and attempting to create Antoinette into a new person (hence Bertha), we are given access to his thoughts and his confusion.  Rhys give us the "other side" of Rochester also.  The third part starts with Grace Poole's voice (Antoinette's prison guard of Jane Eyre), and ends in Antoinette's mind.

    Antoinette appears as a shadowy unsubstantial character in Jane Eyre; Rhys turns the tables in Wide Sargasso Sea, by creating a vivid energectic Antoinette and only alludes to Jane in the shadows.  This is Antoinette's story, not Jane's.

    Rhys doesn't try to change Antointette's ultimate fate; she bows to Bronte's authorship for that.  Antoinette, sadly ends up in Mr. Rochester's attic, and yes, she does leap to her death after she sets the fire.  (This information can only spoil the ending for anyone who hasn't read Jane Eyre). 

    But Rhys manages to change the meaning behind Antoinette's death.  Instead of the fire resulting from the deranged antics of a lunatic madwoman, it is Antoinette's triumphant leap into death to regain her identity and to resist being "colonized" by Rochestor.  (this novel is filled with post-colonial references)

    I urge everyone to pick up Jean Rhys's Wide Sargasso Sea.  It is actually a short read, especially in comparison to Jane Eyre, but it is an unforgettable one. 

     

    Ratings (100 pt scale)
    Overall Rating - 95

    This review has (1) response 

     
    • response from BLNicholas
    • I loved this book the first time I read it. It's so delightfully rich in every way. Excellent review, I love the way you refer to Jane Eyre. Yes, there IS always another side to the story!
    •  
     
    Excerpts

    From Part 3 - Antoinette has become Bertha Mason (from Jane Eyre)

    There is one window high up- you cannot see out of it. My bed had doors but they have been taken away. There is not much else in the room. Her (Grace Poole's) bed, a black press, the table in the middle and the two black chairs carved with fruit and flowers....Looking at the tapestry one day I recognized my mother dressed in an evening gown but with bare feet. She looked away from me, over my head just as she used to do. I woudn't tell Grace this. Her name oughtn't be Grace. Names matter, like when he (Mr. Rochestor) wouldn't call me Antoinette, and I saw Antoinette driftng out of the window with her scents, her pretty clothes and her looking-glass.....

    All the people who had been staying in the house had gone, for the bedroom doors were shut, but it seemed to me that someone was following me, someone was chasing me, laughing. Sometimes I looked to the right or to the left but I never looked behind me for I did not want to see that ghost of a woman who they say haunts this place.