Books to Make You Laugh & Think
booklist by JonIrwin
DJR Suggested Reads
Welcome, Guest!
join djr  |  help
EARMARKED | MESSAGES | SUBSCRIPTIONS
 
news rss
Published March 2nd, 2008
Instead of Worrying About the Death of the Novel, How About Calling a Memoir a Novel When It’s Not a Memoir?

Written by Brenda Nicholas

In the headlines lately—in the bookish universe— is the story of the Belgian writer, Misha Defonseca, who admits that her memoir, "Misha: A Memoir of the Holocaust Years," about escaping the Nazis during WWII by running away with a pack of wolves, is a fabrication.

I don’t know about you, but I wonder when/if the novel has inherited such a bad rap that emerging writers feel the need to disown it entirely? If this is the sad case than writers need to step up to the challenge and write stories that live up to the lost novel’s esteem.

Defonseca's truth-be-told story claims the memoir is really a fantasy that evolved from A.) her tough life and B.) her childhood fascination with wolves. She claims "Apart from my grandfather, I hated the people who looked after me. They treated me badly … [I] always felt Jewish," and she says "There are times when it is difficult for me to tell the difference between what was reality and what was my interior universe."

In other words, she has classic psychological problems that fueled her creative juices in a way that transforms the people who raised her into wolves. I can think of a number of honest ways she could have approached her story and still called it a memoir.

Or, she could have called it a novel.



- categories - News
- has (1) response - [login to respond]
Responses

by sbarranca
I think this was an extremely interesting news item. I love the novel, so I hate to think that people have a bad view of the novel. But, you are right, lately there has been a "rash of memoirs" that later turn out not to be memoirs. Maybe authors feel that in order for their works to sell, it has to be considered real? I don't know; you've given me food for thought!
 
Featured Members
pcontino
Unapologetic Bibliophile
36 shelved books
 
stevedolph
sucker for the absurd, the ironic
27 shelved books
Recent Book Reviews
The China Lover, by Ian Burma
The one job qualification necessary for becoming celebrity is reinvention. Part this has to do with the reality and economics of the business: Marlon Brando had to audition for The Godfather because ...
reviewed by pcontino
[see full review]
 
Fahrenheit 451, by Ray Bradbury
Many great minds throughout history have commented on the invisible war waged between the written word and technology. Kafka referred to the dawn of motion picture as the...
reviewed by BLNicholas
[see full review]
 
American Wife , by Curtis Sittenfeld
It seemed like a good idea: a sexed-up, fictionalized autobiography of Laura Bush. For eight years the First Lady has been the "silent partner" in a White House that can boast that it changed the cou...
reviewed by pcontino
[see full review]
 
The Ha-Ha, by Dave King
This is Dave King's debut fictional novel, and it is superb. It is centered around Howie, a Vietnam Vet. He became disabled in the war and has been trying to rebuild his life ever since. His disabi...
reviewed by sbarranca
[see full review]
 
Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire is the novel that took this series to a whole new level. Not only is it more complicated, dramatic, and suspenseful than the first three, but it is also the found...
reviewed by sbarranca
[see full review]
 
more reviews >>